Difference between revisions of "Exclusion Act"
m (Text replacement - "http:" to "https:") |
|||
| (12 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | There have been | + | There have been several '''Exclusion Acts''' at [[Worldcons]], all of which were controversial and had long-lasting ill effects. |
| + | |||
| + | The term is also bandied about anytime a [[convention]] or [[fan]] group bans or excludes one or more [[fen]], such as when [[Al Ashley]], hosting the [[1943 Michiconference]] at the [[Slan Shack]] (his house in [[Battle Creek]]), told [[Cosmic Circle|Cosmic]] [[Claude Degler]] he wasn’t welcome and turned him away. | ||
== (1) At [[NYCon I]]== | == (1) At [[NYCon I]]== | ||
| − | At the | + | At the [[First Worldcon]] in 1939, [[NYCon I]], the [[Triumvirs]] who were running the show ([[Sam Moskowitz]], [[Will Sykora]] and [[James V. Taurasi]]), citing "conflicts" which had occurred at the [[Newark convention]] brought on by [[Don Wollheim]] and other [[Futurians]], ultimately denied entry to six members of the [[New York Futurian Society]] -– Wollheim, [[Robert A. W. Lowndes]], [[Cyril Kornbluth]], [[Jack Gillespie]], [[Fred Pohl]] and [[John Michel]]. |
| + | |||
| + | Although the Triumvirs had talked about the possibility earlier, actually doing so was apparently an on-the-spot decision made when attempts to negotiate an alternative failed (Wollheim and Moskowitz could not agree upon terms allowing their admission) and upon the discovery of "[[A Warning!]]", a "[[Michelist]]" (essentially pro-[[Communist]]) pamphlet written and distributed by [[Dave Kyle]]. At least four [[Futurians]] – Dave Kyle (ironically), [[Richard Wilson]], [[Jack Rubinson]] and [[Leslie Perri]] –- were not barred. The reaction of [[fandom]] as a whole, while not necessarily pro-Futurian, was very definitely anti-Exclusion. | ||
| + | |||
| + | See the [[Fancyclopedia 1]] and [[Fancy2]] articles below. | ||
| − | + | *[https://www.jophan.org/mimosa/m06/kyle.htm “The Great Exclusion Act of 1939”] by [[Dave Kyle]]. | |
| + | *[https://www.jophan.org/mimosa/m22/kyle.htm “Caravan to the Stars”] by [[Dave Kyle]]. | ||
== (2) At [[NYCon II]]== | == (2) At [[NYCon II]]== | ||
| − | The mini-Exclusion | + | The mini-Exclusion took place the next time a [[Worldcon]] was held in [[New York]], the 1956 [[NYCon II]], when the convention [[chairman]] was [[Dave Kyle]], one of the [[Futurians]] who'd been allowed to enter [[NYCon I]]. Kyle kept those who had not purchased a [[banquet]] ticket from hearing the after-dinner talk by ''Li’l Abner'' [[cartoonist]] Al Capp or any of the rest of the proceedings. See [[Balcony Insurgents]] for the full details (or at least fuller than this) of how "[[Dave Kyle Says You Can't Sit Here]]". |
== (3) The [[Breendoggle]]== | == (3) The [[Breendoggle]]== | ||
| − | See the separate article on the [[Breendoggle]] ( | + | See the separate article on the [[Breendoggle]] (aka the [[Breen]] [[Boondoggle]]). |
| + | |||
| + | == (4) The Worldcon 76 Case == | ||
| + | The 2018 [[Worldcon 76]]'s ban of an author based on his statement that he intended to violate the [[con]]’s [[Code of Conduct]], which resulted in a multi-year [[lawsuit]] ending in a settlement in which the [[con]] had to issue an apology and pay the complainant $4,000. | ||
{{fancy2|text= | {{fancy2|text= | ||
| − | The [[Triumvirs]], in planning for the [[NYCon I]], considered excluding their feud-opponents the [[Futurians]] from the gathering to avoid such conflict as had marred the [[Newark Convention]]. No decision was reached, but when the conventioneers began arriving [[Taurasi]] stopped [[Wollheim]] [[Lowndes]] [[Kornbluth]] and [[Gillespie]] and told them they couldn't enter the hall. (It appears that some pushing and shoving was done about this time, but no blood drawn.) [[Moskowitz]] came out and they talked and argued for about fifteen minutes, [[SaM]] telling | + | The [[Triumvirs]], in planning for the [[NYCon I]], considered excluding their feud-opponents the [[Futurians]] from the gathering to avoid such conflict as had marred the [[Newark Convention]]. No decision was reached, but when the conventioneers began arriving [[Taurasi]] stopped [[Wollheim]] [[Lowndes]] [[Kornbluth]] and [[Jack Gillespie|Gillespie]] and told them they couldn't enter the hall. (It appears that some pushing and shoving was done about this time, but no blood drawn.) [[Moskowitz]] came out and they talked and argued for about fifteen minutes, [[SaM]] telling Wollheim that they would admit the four if the Futurians promised "not to do anything to harm the progress of the convention." Wollheim refused to accept conditional admittance but in another passage of the conversation said they could be ejected if they didn't behave. Moskowitz sent for the superintendent of the building, but couldn't get in touch with him. Finally he went looking for [[Sykora]] to consult with him, but on the way found a stack of [[Michelistic]] sheets and pamphlets (which [[Pohl]] and others had run off the night before for distribution at the [[con]]) where Pohl and [[Michel]] had cached them behind a radiator. In the end, all six -- Wollheim, Lowndes, Kornbluth, Gillespie, Pohl, and Michel -- were refused admittance. Police had been called but were not put into service by the Triumvirs. |
| − | Many attendees, including [[Morojo]] of LA, [[Dale Hart|Hart]] of Texas, and [[Frances Swisher|Mrs Swisher]] of Massachusetts, urged the [[convention committee]] to admit the six, and other members of the [[FSNY]] including [[Kyle]] [[Dick Wilson|Wilson]] [[Rubinson]] and [[Leslie Perri]] were not barred. In the afternoon, | + | Many attendees, including [[Morojo]] of [[LA]], [[Dale Hart|Hart]] of [[Texas]], and [[Frances Swisher|Mrs Swisher]] of [[Massachusetts]], urged the [[convention committee]] to admit the six, and other members of the [[FSNY]] including [[Kyle]] [[Dick Wilson|Wilson]] [[Rubinson]] and [[Leslie Perri]] were not barred. In the afternoon, Kyle gained the floor on a pretext and held it to make a motion that the excluded fans be admitted. But [[Sykora]] as [[chairman]] talked a while and changed the subject. (There was no [[fan]] discussion period, and no motions were recognized, during the [[convention]].) On the third day of the [[con]], while most attendees were watching a fan baseball game on Flushing Flats, the [[Futurians]] and their sympathizers met at a [[Futurian Conference]] to discuss the Exclusion Act, but this was not a part of the convention. |
| − | Because of its dramatic quality, as well as the issues involved, the X Act came to dominate talk about the convention as time passed. The [[Triumvirs]] tried to do as they had done in rising to power -- ignore the existence of [[fan feuds]] -- but finally, at the [[PhilCo]] in the fall, [[Moskowitz]] published their side of the matter (theretofore unrepresented and uninquired about) adding charges that the [[Futurians]]' refusal to make the promise asked showed that they wanted to be excluded, in order to better their strategic position in the feud if they weren't able to upset the convention itself. Resentment over the thing decreased somewhat thereafter but the [[Triumvirs]] were never forgiven. | + | Because of its dramatic quality, as well as the issues involved, the X Act came to dominate talk about the convention as time passed. The [[Triumvirs]] tried to do as they had done in rising to power -- ignore the existence of [[fan feuds]] -- but finally, at the [[PhilCo]] in the fall, [[Moskowitz]] published their side of the matter (theretofore unrepresented and uninquired about) adding charges that the [[Futurians]]' refusal to make the promise asked showed that they wanted to be excluded, in order to better their strategic position in the [[feud]] if they weren't able to upset the convention itself. Resentment over the thing decreased somewhat thereafter but the [[Triumvirs]] were never forgiven. |
The Second or Little Exclusion Act, so called, was a piffling affair at the [[NYCon II]] when the con committee briefly refused to allow any attendees who had not paid for the banquet ($7) to listen to the dinner speakers from the balcony overlooking the hall. But this was resented rather as [[fuggheadedness]] than malice. | The Second or Little Exclusion Act, so called, was a piffling affair at the [[NYCon II]] when the con committee briefly refused to allow any attendees who had not paid for the banquet ($7) to listen to the dinner speakers from the balcony overlooking the hall. But this was resented rather as [[fuggheadedness]] than malice. | ||
| Line 23: | Line 33: | ||
{{fancy1|text= | {{fancy1|text= | ||
| − | Fearing conflict such as marred the [[Newark Convention]], the [[Triumvirs]] discussed the question of admitting the [[Futurians]] in planning the [[World Convention]]. No decision was arrived at, however; [[Moskowitz]] was less unfavorably inclined toward the [[Futurians]] than [[Sykora]] and [[Taurasi]]. The nite before the Convention, [[Pohl]] and others mimeographed a number of [[Michelistic]] sheets and pamflets to distribute at the WSFC as they had at the Newark gathering. Next morning, as the Conventioneers began arriving, among them were [[Wollheim]], [[Lowndes]], [[Kornbluth]], and [[Gillespie]]. As they started into the hall upstairs, [[Taurasi]] stopped them and said they couldn't go in. It appears that some pushing and shoving was done about this time, but no blood drawn. [[Sam Moskowitz]] came out of the hall and they talked and argued for about fifteen minutes. | + | Fearing conflict such as marred the [[Newark Convention]], the [[Triumvirs]] discussed the question of admitting the [[Futurians]] in planning the [[World Convention]]. No decision was arrived at, however; [[Moskowitz]] was less unfavorably inclined toward the [[Futurians]] than [[Sykora]] and [[Taurasi]]. The nite before the Convention, [[Pohl]] and others [[mimeographed]] a number of [[Michelistic]] sheets and pamflets to distribute at the WSFC as they had at the [[Newark, NJ|Newark]] gathering. Next morning, as the Conventioneers began arriving, among them were [[Wollheim]], [[Lowndes]], [[Kornbluth]], and [[Jack Gillespie|Gillespie]]. As they started into the hall upstairs, [[Taurasi]] stopped them and said they couldn't go in. It appears that some pushing and shoving was done about this time, but no blood drawn. [[Sam Moskowitz]] came out of the hall and they talked and argued for about fifteen minutes. Moskowitz told Wollheim they would admit them if the [[Futurians]] would promise not to "do anything to harm the progress of the Convention". Wollheim refused, but in another passage of the conversation, said they could be ejected if they didn't behave. Moskowitz sent for the superintendent of the building, but couldn't get in touch with him. Finally he said he'd go find [[Sykora]] and consult with him. On the way down, he found the pamflets, apparently hidden behind a radiator, having been left there by Pohl and [[Michel]] who arrived later than the other four. So far your Herodotos has tried to reconstruct the happenings. In the end, those six were refused admittance. Police had been called, but were not put into service by the Triumvirs. |
| − | Unknown to the excluded six, [[Kyle]] had anonymously printed a yellow pamflet warning against an expected effort by the | + | Unknown to the excluded six, [[Kyle]] had anonymously printed a yellow pamflet warning against an expected effort by the Triumvirate to use the Convention to resurrect the [[ISA]] or put across something else thru their parliamentary control. As it turned out, these suspicions were unfounded, for there was no [[fan]] discussion period, and no motions were recognized. Many attendees, including [[Morojo]] of [[LA]], [[Dale Hart|Hart]] of [[Texas]], and [[Frances Swisher|Mrs Swisher]] of [[Massachusetts]], urged the [[convention committee]] to admit the six [[Futurians]]. Other members of the [[FSNY]], including [[Kyle]], [[Dick Wilson|Wilson]], [[Rubinson]], and [[Leslie Perri]], were not barred. In the afternoon, Kyle gained the floor on a pretext and held it to make a motion that the excluded [[fans]] be admitted. [[Sykora]], chairman, talked awhile and changed the subject. |
| − | Because of its dramatic quality, as well as the issues involved, the X Act came more and more to dominate talk about the Convention as time passed. The [[Triumvirs]] attempted to do as they had done in rising to power, ignored the existence of [[fan feuds]]; finally, at the [[Philcon 1939|Philcon]] in the fall, [[Moskowitz]] published an article giving their side of the matter, which had theretofore been unrepresented and uninquired about. He further charged that the [[Futurians]]' refusal to make the promise asked, showed that they wanted to be excluded, in order to better their strategic position in the [[fan]] | + | Because of its dramatic quality, as well as the issues involved, the X Act came more and more to dominate talk about the Convention as time passed. The [[Triumvirs]] attempted to do as they had done in rising to power, ignored the existence of [[fan feuds]]; finally, at the [[Philcon 1939|Philcon]] in the fall, [[Moskowitz]] published an article giving their side of the matter, which had theretofore been unrepresented and uninquired about. He further charged that the [[Futurians]]' refusal to make the promise asked, showed that they wanted to be excluded, in order to better their strategic position in the [[All Fandom was Plunged into War|fan war]], if they weren't to be able to upset the Convention plans. Resentment over the thing decreased somewhat, but [[fandom]] has never forgiven it. |
}} | }} | ||
| − | {{fanhistory}} | + | {{fanhistory | start=1939 | end=1963}} |
[[Category:fancy1]] | [[Category:fancy1]] | ||
[[Category:fancy2]] | [[Category:fancy2]] | ||
| + | [[Category:abomination]] | ||
| + | [[Category:US]] | ||
| + | [[Category:conrunning]] | ||
| + | [[Category:fanspeak]] | ||
Latest revision as of 14:24, 28 November 2022
There have been several Exclusion Acts at Worldcons, all of which were controversial and had long-lasting ill effects.
The term is also bandied about anytime a convention or fan group bans or excludes one or more fen, such as when Al Ashley, hosting the 1943 Michiconference at the Slan Shack (his house in Battle Creek), told Cosmic Claude Degler he wasn’t welcome and turned him away.
(1) At NYCon I[edit]
At the First Worldcon in 1939, NYCon I, the Triumvirs who were running the show (Sam Moskowitz, Will Sykora and James V. Taurasi), citing "conflicts" which had occurred at the Newark convention brought on by Don Wollheim and other Futurians, ultimately denied entry to six members of the New York Futurian Society -– Wollheim, Robert A. W. Lowndes, Cyril Kornbluth, Jack Gillespie, Fred Pohl and John Michel.
Although the Triumvirs had talked about the possibility earlier, actually doing so was apparently an on-the-spot decision made when attempts to negotiate an alternative failed (Wollheim and Moskowitz could not agree upon terms allowing their admission) and upon the discovery of "A Warning!", a "Michelist" (essentially pro-Communist) pamphlet written and distributed by Dave Kyle. At least four Futurians – Dave Kyle (ironically), Richard Wilson, Jack Rubinson and Leslie Perri –- were not barred. The reaction of fandom as a whole, while not necessarily pro-Futurian, was very definitely anti-Exclusion.
See the Fancyclopedia 1 and Fancy2 articles below.
(2) At NYCon II[edit]
The mini-Exclusion took place the next time a Worldcon was held in New York, the 1956 NYCon II, when the convention chairman was Dave Kyle, one of the Futurians who'd been allowed to enter NYCon I. Kyle kept those who had not purchased a banquet ticket from hearing the after-dinner talk by Li’l Abner cartoonist Al Capp or any of the rest of the proceedings. See Balcony Insurgents for the full details (or at least fuller than this) of how "Dave Kyle Says You Can't Sit Here".
(3) The Breendoggle[edit]
See the separate article on the Breendoggle (aka the Breen Boondoggle).
(4) The Worldcon 76 Case[edit]
The 2018 Worldcon 76 in San Jose's ban of an author based on his statement that he intended to violate the con’s Code of Conduct, which resulted in a multi-year lawsuit ending in a settlement in which the con had to issue an apology and pay the complainant $4,000.
| From Fancyclopedia 2, ca. 1959 |
| The Triumvirs, in planning for the NYCon I, considered excluding their feud-opponents the Futurians from the gathering to avoid such conflict as had marred the Newark Convention. No decision was reached, but when the conventioneers began arriving Taurasi stopped Wollheim Lowndes Kornbluth and Gillespie and told them they couldn't enter the hall. (It appears that some pushing and shoving was done about this time, but no blood drawn.) Moskowitz came out and they talked and argued for about fifteen minutes, SaM telling Wollheim that they would admit the four if the Futurians promised "not to do anything to harm the progress of the convention." Wollheim refused to accept conditional admittance but in another passage of the conversation said they could be ejected if they didn't behave. Moskowitz sent for the superintendent of the building, but couldn't get in touch with him. Finally he went looking for Sykora to consult with him, but on the way found a stack of Michelistic sheets and pamphlets (which Pohl and others had run off the night before for distribution at the con) where Pohl and Michel had cached them behind a radiator. In the end, all six -- Wollheim, Lowndes, Kornbluth, Gillespie, Pohl, and Michel -- were refused admittance. Police had been called but were not put into service by the Triumvirs.
Many attendees, including Morojo of LA, Hart of Texas, and Mrs Swisher of Massachusetts, urged the convention committee to admit the six, and other members of the FSNY including Kyle Wilson Rubinson and Leslie Perri were not barred. In the afternoon, Kyle gained the floor on a pretext and held it to make a motion that the excluded fans be admitted. But Sykora as chairman talked a while and changed the subject. (There was no fan discussion period, and no motions were recognized, during the convention.) On the third day of the con, while most attendees were watching a fan baseball game on Flushing Flats, the Futurians and their sympathizers met at a Futurian Conference to discuss the Exclusion Act, but this was not a part of the convention. Because of its dramatic quality, as well as the issues involved, the X Act came to dominate talk about the convention as time passed. The Triumvirs tried to do as they had done in rising to power -- ignore the existence of fan feuds -- but finally, at the PhilCo in the fall, Moskowitz published their side of the matter (theretofore unrepresented and uninquired about) adding charges that the Futurians' refusal to make the promise asked showed that they wanted to be excluded, in order to better their strategic position in the feud if they weren't able to upset the convention itself. Resentment over the thing decreased somewhat thereafter but the Triumvirs were never forgiven. The Second or Little Exclusion Act, so called, was a piffling affair at the NYCon II when the con committee briefly refused to allow any attendees who had not paid for the banquet ($7) to listen to the dinner speakers from the balcony overlooking the hall. But this was resented rather as fuggheadedness than malice. |
| From Fancyclopedia 1, ca. 1944 |
| Fearing conflict such as marred the Newark Convention, the Triumvirs discussed the question of admitting the Futurians in planning the World Convention. No decision was arrived at, however; Moskowitz was less unfavorably inclined toward the Futurians than Sykora and Taurasi. The nite before the Convention, Pohl and others mimeographed a number of Michelistic sheets and pamflets to distribute at the WSFC as they had at the Newark gathering. Next morning, as the Conventioneers began arriving, among them were Wollheim, Lowndes, Kornbluth, and Gillespie. As they started into the hall upstairs, Taurasi stopped them and said they couldn't go in. It appears that some pushing and shoving was done about this time, but no blood drawn. Sam Moskowitz came out of the hall and they talked and argued for about fifteen minutes. Moskowitz told Wollheim they would admit them if the Futurians would promise not to "do anything to harm the progress of the Convention". Wollheim refused, but in another passage of the conversation, said they could be ejected if they didn't behave. Moskowitz sent for the superintendent of the building, but couldn't get in touch with him. Finally he said he'd go find Sykora and consult with him. On the way down, he found the pamflets, apparently hidden behind a radiator, having been left there by Pohl and Michel who arrived later than the other four. So far your Herodotos has tried to reconstruct the happenings. In the end, those six were refused admittance. Police had been called, but were not put into service by the Triumvirs.
Unknown to the excluded six, Kyle had anonymously printed a yellow pamflet warning against an expected effort by the Triumvirate to use the Convention to resurrect the ISA or put across something else thru their parliamentary control. As it turned out, these suspicions were unfounded, for there was no fan discussion period, and no motions were recognized. Many attendees, including Morojo of LA, Hart of Texas, and Mrs Swisher of Massachusetts, urged the convention committee to admit the six Futurians. Other members of the FSNY, including Kyle, Wilson, Rubinson, and Leslie Perri, were not barred. In the afternoon, Kyle gained the floor on a pretext and held it to make a motion that the excluded fans be admitted. Sykora, chairman, talked awhile and changed the subject. Because of its dramatic quality, as well as the issues involved, the X Act came more and more to dominate talk about the Convention as time passed. The Triumvirs attempted to do as they had done in rising to power, ignored the existence of fan feuds; finally, at the Philcon in the fall, Moskowitz published an article giving their side of the matter, which had theretofore been unrepresented and uninquired about. He further charged that the Futurians' refusal to make the promise asked, showed that they wanted to be excluded, in order to better their strategic position in the fan war, if they weren't to be able to upset the Convention plans. Resentment over the thing decreased somewhat, but fandom has never forgiven it. |
| Fanhistory | 1939—1963 |
| This is a fanhistory page. Please add more detail. |
