Difference between revisions of "Discon III"
| (17 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
The 79th [[Worldcon]], and [[Baltiwash Worldcons|fifth in the Baltimore/Washington area]], '''Discon III''' ('''DC3'''), originally scheduled for August 25–29, 2021, was held December 15–19, 2021, at the Omni [[Shoreham]] Hotel in [[Washington, DC]]. The [[con]] was sponsored by the [[Baltimore-Washington Area Worldcon Association]] ("BAWAWA"). | The 79th [[Worldcon]], and [[Baltiwash Worldcons|fifth in the Baltimore/Washington area]], '''Discon III''' ('''DC3'''), originally scheduled for August 25–29, 2021, was held December 15–19, 2021, at the Omni [[Shoreham]] Hotel in [[Washington, DC]]. The [[con]] was sponsored by the [[Baltimore-Washington Area Worldcon Association]] ("BAWAWA"). | ||
| − | [[GoHs]]: [[Author GoH]], [[Nancy Kress]]; [[Artist GoH]], [[John Harris]]; [[Fan GoH]], [[Ben Yalow]]; <s>[[Editor GoH]]: [[Toni Weisskopf]];</s> [[Special Guests]], [[Malka Older]], [[Sheree Renée Thomas]] and last-minute add-on [[Andrea Hairston]]. | + | [[GoHs]]: [[Author GoH]], [[Nancy Kress]]; [[Artist GoH]], [[John Harris]] (who did not attend); [[Fan GoH]], [[Ben Yalow]]; <s>[[Editor GoH]]: [[Toni Weisskopf]];</s> [[Special Guests]], [[Malka Older]] (who did not attend), [[Sheree Renée Thomas]] and last-minute add-on [[Andrea Hairston]]. |
| − | It was first co-chaired by [[Bill Lawhorn]] and [[Colette Fozard]]. Fozard resigned in January 2021, and Lawhorn in June. After a short search for a replacement, [[Mary Robinette Kowal]] joined the [[concom]] and took over in early July | + | It was first [[co-chaired]] by [[Bill Lawhorn]] and [[Colette Fozard]]. Fozard resigned in January 2021, and Lawhorn in June. After a short search for a replacement, [[Mary Robinette Kowal]], a [[pro]], joined the [[concom]] and took over in early July, serving through the convention. |
The [[DC in 2021]] bid was [[2021 Site Selection|selected]] at [[Dublin 2019]] in an uncontested race and conducted the [[2023 Worldcon Site Selection]], won by [[Chengdu Worldcon]]. | The [[DC in 2021]] bid was [[2021 Site Selection|selected]] at [[Dublin 2019]] in an uncontested race and conducted the [[2023 Worldcon Site Selection]], won by [[Chengdu Worldcon]]. | ||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
=Disasters= | =Disasters= | ||
| − | The [[con]] was so fraught with troubles it may go down in [[fanhistory]] as Discon Disastrous. | + | The [[con]] was so fraught with troubles it may go down in [[fanhistory]] as '''Discon Disastrous'''. |
==Covid-19== | ==Covid-19== | ||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
Flare-ups of the Omicron strain of Covid-19 just before the convention caused many members to decide not to attend in person. Among them was [[Special Guest]] [[Malka Older]], who decided to attend only virtually since her children were not old enough to be vaccinated. Since she and [[Sheree Renée Thomas]] were meant to co-host the [[Hugo Ceremony]], the concom invited an additional special guest, [[Andrea Hairston]], for that role. | Flare-ups of the Omicron strain of Covid-19 just before the convention caused many members to decide not to attend in person. Among them was [[Special Guest]] [[Malka Older]], who decided to attend only virtually since her children were not old enough to be vaccinated. Since she and [[Sheree Renée Thomas]] were meant to co-host the [[Hugo Ceremony]], the concom invited an additional special guest, [[Andrea Hairston]], for that role. | ||
| − | Despite the con’s policies and members’ precautions, | + | Despite the con’s policies and members’ precautions, at least 31 attendees tested positive for Covid-19 during or just after Discon III (which had somewhere between 2000 and 3000 attendees). A January 12 report stated:<blockquote>The only cluster event we saw evidence of was the [[WSFS Business Meeting]].... The WSFS business meeting ... has a disproportionate number of cases relative to the percent of DisCon III members who attended it. Our best guess is that the WSFS business meeting involved a lot of talking, which generates more aerosols, and consistent repeated exposure. The other panel rooms were cleared every hour for a half-hour break but the business meeting was not.</blockquote> |
===Hotels=== | ===Hotels=== | ||
In the summer of 2020, the Marriott Wardman Park announced that the hotel, which had been closed since March due to [[Covid-19]], might shut down permanently, with a final decision scheduled for sometime in the Fall of 2020. Subsequently, the Wardman Park’s owners filed for bankruptcy, announced the hotel’s permanent closing, and their intent to sell the property. | In the summer of 2020, the Marriott Wardman Park announced that the hotel, which had been closed since March due to [[Covid-19]], might shut down permanently, with a final decision scheduled for sometime in the Fall of 2020. Subsequently, the Wardman Park’s owners filed for bankruptcy, announced the hotel’s permanent closing, and their intent to sell the property. | ||
| − | ==Controversies == | + | ==Controversies== |
===Fired GoH=== | ===Fired GoH=== | ||
| − | The [[convention]] had announced [[Baen Books]]’ [[Toni Weisskopf]] as [[Editor GoH]]. | + | The [[convention]] had announced [[Baen Books]]’ [[Toni Weisskopf]] as [[Editor GoH]]. After [[Jason Sanford]] {{link |website=https://www.patreon.com/posts/baen-books-forum-47582408|text=publicized}} on February 15, 2021, what he viewed as toxic content by some users of a few of Baen’s online forums, the [[concom]] announced it was “monitoring” the situation. Weisskopf took down the forums the next day, promising to investigate. However, Discon issued a {{link|website=https://discon3.org/news/update-on-editor-guest-of-honor/ |text=statement on February 19}}, saying, in part:<blockquote> DisCon III condemns the violent and hostile content found within Baen Books’ forums. We also cannot condone the fact such content was enabled and allowed to ferment for so long. We want to make it clear abusive behavior is not, and will not be, tolerated at DisCon III. Such behavior goes entirely against our already established policies concerning inclusivity and creating a welcoming environment for our members.... As a result, after discussion with her, we have notified Toni Weisskopf we are removing her as a Guest of Honor for DisCon III.</blockquote> |
This marked the first time a Worldcon had ever removed a GoH. The decision was controversial, to say the least. Several concom members and volunteers resigned in the wake of the announcement and some con members said on social media that they would not attend. | This marked the first time a Worldcon had ever removed a GoH. The decision was controversial, to say the least. Several concom members and volunteers resigned in the wake of the announcement and some con members said on social media that they would not attend. | ||
| Line 36: | Line 36: | ||
===Resignations=== | ===Resignations=== | ||
| − | [[Bill Lawhorn]] and [[Colette Fozard]] were originally [[co-chair]]s, but Fozard resigned in January 2021 due to abuse from the online community over the Worldcon’s (quickly rescinded) announcements regarding limits on certain credits for large teams receiving [[Hugo]] nominations. She issued a {{link|website= | + | [[Bill Lawhorn]] and [[Colette Fozard]] were originally [[co-chair]]s, but Fozard resigned in January 2021 due to abuse from the online community over the Worldcon’s (quickly rescinded) announcements regarding limits on certain credits for large teams receiving [[Hugo]] nominations. She issued a {{link|website=https://file770.com/fozard-guest-post-about-resigning-as-worldcon-co-chair/ |text=statement on ''File 770''.}} |
| − | Other resignations included [[Jared Dashoff]], the [[WSFS]] Division Head ([ | + | Other resignations included [[Jared Dashoff]], the [[WSFS]] Division Head ([https://file770.com/fozard-guest-post-about-resigning-as-worldcon-co-chair/comment-page-1/#comment-1259710 explained here]), the Hugo Administrator, the Facilities Division Heads, and several others. Then, in June 2021, the ''replacement'' Hugo Administration team resigned en masse. |
Shortly afterward, a beleaguered Lawhorn resigned, according to an announcement on June 25, 2021. | Shortly afterward, a beleaguered Lawhorn resigned, according to an announcement on June 25, 2021. | ||
| − | ===Latinx Fanhistory Error === | + | ===Latinx Fanhistory Error=== |
| − | On September 3, 2021, DisCon III [https://discon3.org/news/discon-iii-announces-vice-chairs/ announced] that [[Marguerite Smith]] and [[Lauren Raye Snow]] were joining the [[concom]] as vice chairs, describing Snow as “the first Latinx to serve as a [[Vice Chair]]. | + | On September 3, 2021, DisCon III [https://discon3.org/news/discon-iii-announces-vice-chairs/ announced] that [[Marguerite Smith]] and [[Lauren Raye Snow]] were joining the [[concom]] as vice chairs, describing Snow as “the first Latinx to serve as a [[Vice Chair]]” of a Worldcon. This was untrue, as [[Fred Duarte]] was a vice chair for [[LoneStarCon 2]] in 1997, and for all anyone knows, someone else with that heritage may have had the job earlier yet. |
| − | Not every Worldcon has vice chairs, nobody maintains a historical listing of fans who held the title, nor have [[conventions]] generally highlighted the ethnicity of their concom members, so the initial mistake might be forgivable poor research. However, [[Karen Meschke]], [[chair]] of LoneStarCon 2 and the late Duarte’s ex-wife, immediately contacted Discon to correct the error, asking, “Could the wording be changed to first female Latinx Vice Chair and Fred be added as a footnote?” After Meschke notified two different Discon advisors and got no action, she [ | + | Not every Worldcon has vice chairs, nobody maintains a historical listing of fans who held the title, nor have [[conventions]] generally highlighted the ethnicity of their concom members, so the initial mistake might be forgivable poor research. However, [[Karen Meschke]], [[chair]] of LoneStarCon 2 and the late Duarte’s ex-wife, immediately contacted Discon to correct the error, asking, “Could the wording be changed to first female Latinx Vice Chair and Fred be added as a footnote?” After Meschke notified two different Discon advisors and got no action, she [https://file770.com/meschke-calls-on-discon-iii-to-correct-fanhistorical-note-in-press-release/ went public on October 19] in a guest post at ''[[File 770]]''. |
After others intervened, the online announcement was amended, with Fred mentioned in a footnote, and the correction was sent out on October 28 with no word on why it took two months. | After others intervened, the online announcement was amended, with Fred mentioned in a footnote, and the correction was sent out on October 28 with no word on why it took two months. | ||
===Hugos === | ===Hugos === | ||
| − | The first Hugo controversy had to with policies over how many of the people behind a nominee would be listed on the ballot, engraved on the award and welcome at limited-attendance events. A second, possibly related, internal flap (see [ | + | The first Hugo controversy had to do with policies over how many of the people behind a nominee would be listed on the ballot, engraved on the award and welcome at limited-attendance events. A second, possibly related, internal flap (see [https://file770.com/another-discon-iii-hugo-administration-team-resigns/ ''File 770'']) led to another round of [[Discon III#Resignations|committee resignations]]. |
Then, among the [[2021 Hugos]] nominations for [[Best Related Work]] was “[[George R.R. Martin]] Can Fuck Off Into the Sun, Or: The 2020 Hugo Awards Ceremony (Rageblog Edition),” a blog post critical of Martin’s performance as [[MC]] of the Hugo ceremony at [[CoNZealand]]. Since it achieved enough nominations to appear on the ballot (37), Hugo Administrator [[Linda Deneroff]] (part of the ''third'' Hugo Administration team) allowed it, apparently without considering whether it was in violation of Discon’s “established policies concerning inclusivity and creating a welcoming environment for our members.” The Code of Conduct explicitly forbade “Comments directly intended to belittle, offend, or cause discomfort including telling others they are not welcome and should leave.” | Then, among the [[2021 Hugos]] nominations for [[Best Related Work]] was “[[George R.R. Martin]] Can Fuck Off Into the Sun, Or: The 2020 Hugo Awards Ceremony (Rageblog Edition),” a blog post critical of Martin’s performance as [[MC]] of the Hugo ceremony at [[CoNZealand]]. Since it achieved enough nominations to appear on the ballot (37), Hugo Administrator [[Linda Deneroff]] (part of the ''third'' Hugo Administration team) allowed it, apparently without considering whether it was in violation of Discon’s “established policies concerning inclusivity and creating a welcoming environment for our members.” The Code of Conduct explicitly forbade “Comments directly intended to belittle, offend, or cause discomfort including telling others they are not welcome and should leave.” | ||
| Line 58: | Line 58: | ||
Editor GoH [[Toni Weisskopf]], who was disinvited under those same policies, received sufficient nominations for the [[Best Editor, Long Form Hugo]] to appear on the ballot, but, according to the administrators, withdrew. | Editor GoH [[Toni Weisskopf]], who was disinvited under those same policies, received sufficient nominations for the [[Best Editor, Long Form Hugo]] to appear on the ballot, but, according to the administrators, withdrew. | ||
| − | The awards ceremony itself was delayed due to | + | The awards ceremony itself was delayed for an hour due to a minor fire in the ballroom. |
===Christian Opening Ceremonies=== | ===Christian Opening Ceremonies=== | ||
[[Opening Ceremonies]] featured a concert by the Duke Ellington School of the Arts Show Choir of Washington, DC, which had been invited by [[Chair]] [[Mary Robinette Kowal]], who had previously announced, “I was a theater kid, and as soon as I learned about the Duke Ellington School of the Arts, I knew we needed to have them involved as a true expression of D.C. We are thrilled that the students will join us both on stage and behind the scenes. The show choir’s performance will be the highlight of the Opening Ceremonies.” | [[Opening Ceremonies]] featured a concert by the Duke Ellington School of the Arts Show Choir of Washington, DC, which had been invited by [[Chair]] [[Mary Robinette Kowal]], who had previously announced, “I was a theater kid, and as soon as I learned about the Duke Ellington School of the Arts, I knew we needed to have them involved as a true expression of D.C. We are thrilled that the students will join us both on stage and behind the scenes. The show choir’s performance will be the highlight of the Opening Ceremonies.” | ||
| − | What was not announced ahead of time was the choir’s program, which was devoted to Christian, gospel and Christmas music. Many [[Jews]] and other non-Christian [[fans]] found this inappropriate as part of Worldcon’s official opening event, if not offensive and a violation of Discon’s “established policies concerning inclusivity and creating a welcoming environment for our members.” | + | What was not announced ahead of time was the choir’s program, which was devoted to Christian, gospel and Christmas music. Many [[Jews]] and other non-Christian [[fans]] found this inappropriate as part of Worldcon’s official opening event, if not offensive and a violation of Discon’s “established policies concerning inclusivity and creating a welcoming environment for our members.” No one connected to the convention ever made any official acknowledgment of the complaints. |
===Site Selection=== | ===Site Selection=== | ||
| − | [[2023 Site Selection]] was also fraught | + | See [[2023 Site Selection]], which was also fraught. |
===Raytheon Sponsorship === | ===Raytheon Sponsorship === | ||
| − | Discon accepted sponsorship funds from Raytheon | + | Discon III accepted sponsorship funds from Raytheon Intelligence and Space, a high tech, aerospace and weapons manufacturer, which some [[fans]] and [[pro]]s found upsetting. After this was publicized, Chair Mary Kowal apologized post-con, saying the sponsorship did not meet Discon’s Code of Conduct and “aims to build an inclusive community for all fans.” ([https://discon3.org/news/statement-and-apology-on-discon-iii-sponsorship/ Online here.]) |
| − | =See | + | The apology offended another group of fans, many of whom work for in the aerospace and military/industrial complex. Not to mention the people who were already unhappy about other issues for which there was no apology. |
| − | * For other especially troubled Worldcons, see [[NyCon]] (1939), [[NorWesCon (Worldcon)]] (1950), [[Iguanacon]] (1978), [[ConStellation]] (1983) and [[Nolacon 2]] (1988). The [[Sad Puppies|Sad and Rabid Puppies]] caused controversies for the 2014–16 cons, and [[ConJose 2]] (2018) was afflicted by [[legal matters]]. | + | |
| − | * [https://discon3.org/ Website.] | + | Kowal further said Discon would “make an anonymous contribution to an organization dedicated to peace, equal to the amount we received from Raytheon.” However, this would appear to violate the [[WSFS Constitution]], which requires that [[Worldcons]] “dispose of surplus funds remaining after accounts are settled for its convention for the benefit of WSFS as a whole” and “file annual financial reports regarding the disbursement of that surplus.” |
| + | |||
| + | ===Accessibility Issues=== | ||
| + | As the Omni Shoreham opened in 1930, the site had accessibility issues. There were steps between different parts of the lobby and to the main restaurant. The accessibility of parts of the hotel, coupled with the slow and small elevators, caused problems for some fans. Some [[programming]] was not accessible. There were some special elevators for people who needed them that were not marked until a day after the convention started. Due to staffing issues at the Omni Shoreham, there was no room service. | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Author]] and access advocate [[Mari Ness]] [https://marikness.wordpress.com/2021/12/21/are-we-really-doing-this-again-discon-iii-accessibility-and-genre-cons/ posted about the difficulties] at length, particularly condemning the con’s communications about potential issues. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ===Videos === | ||
| + | Recordings of [[programming]] were made available online only for three weeks in January 2022 and accessible only to Discon III members. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Discon III Itself== | ||
| + | Despite the many issues around Discon III, many members had an enjoyable conference, especially the opportunity to see friends in person after 21 months of [[Concellation]]. The weather was mostly warm and dry. Most of the party suites were large and the parties were well-attended. | ||
| + | |||
| + | The Exhibit Hall and [[Dealers Room]] were in a portion of the garage, which led to parking issues throughout the convention. | ||
| + | |||
| + | At-con [[Registration]] had long lines, with up to 2-hour long waits on Wednesday. | ||
| + | |||
| + | The [[Program]] was mostly held in person, with some virtual items held during the course of the convention. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ===Attendance:=== | ||
| + | 2,359 [[attending members]] plus 952 virtual with 8,721 total members (including some 3,000 [[supporting memberships]] from [[China]]). These [[membership]] figures are from [https://www.smofinfo.com/LL/TheLongList.html The Long List;] however, [https://locusmag.com/2022/02/discon-iii-report-and-2021-wsfs-business-meeting/ ''Locus'' reported] 2,359 attendees + 1,197 virtual, totaling 9,293. | ||
| + | |||
| + | ===Business Meeting === | ||
| + | Besides the activity detailed under [[2023 Site Selection]], the notable actions of the [[WSFS Business Meeting]] were to ratify the [[Lodestar Award]] and the [[Best Series Hugo]], passed on from 2020, and in new business, a change in [[memberships]], which clarifies that one is paying for membership in [[WSFS]] and making that nontransferable. The motion passed and went to [[Chicon 8#Business Meeting Highlights|Chicon 8]] for ratification. | ||
| + | |||
| + | As noted under [[Discon III#Covid-19|Covid-19]], the [[BM]] proved a cluster event. | ||
| + | |||
| + | =See Also= | ||
| + | * For other especially-troubled Worldcons, see [[NyCon]] (1939), [[NorWesCon (Worldcon)]] (1950), [[Iguanacon]] (1978), [[ConStellation]] (1983) and [[Nolacon 2]] (1988). The [[Sad Puppies|Sad and Rabid Puppies]] caused controversies for the 2014–16 cons, and [[ConJose 2]] (2018) was afflicted by [[legal matters]]. | ||
| + | * [https://discon3.org/ Discon III Website.] | ||
* {{conpubs|series=Worldcon |con=Discon III}}. | * {{conpubs|series=Worldcon |con=Discon III}}. | ||
* [https://discon3.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Agenda-as-of-20211210-Version-19.pdf Business Meeting Agenda.] | * [https://discon3.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Agenda-as-of-20211210-Version-19.pdf Business Meeting Agenda.] | ||
| + | * [https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL0oLnkb-s4Yc2VS8jRy5uSViTaxr8hTey Business Meeting videos]. | ||
* [https://discon3.org/about/coc/ Discon III Code of Conduct.] | * [https://discon3.org/about/coc/ Discon III Code of Conduct.] | ||
| + | * [[Hugo In Memoriam Scroll 2021]]. | ||
Latest revision as of 02:12, 11 May 2023
The 79th Worldcon, and fifth in the Baltimore/Washington area, Discon III (DC3), originally scheduled for August 25–29, 2021, was held December 15–19, 2021, at the Omni Shoreham Hotel in Washington, DC. The con was sponsored by the Baltimore-Washington Area Worldcon Association ("BAWAWA").
GoHs: Author GoH, Nancy Kress; Artist GoH, John Harris (who did not attend); Fan GoH, Ben Yalow; Editor GoH: Toni Weisskopf; Special Guests, Malka Older (who did not attend), Sheree Renée Thomas and last-minute add-on Andrea Hairston.
It was first co-chaired by Bill Lawhorn and Colette Fozard. Fozard resigned in January 2021, and Lawhorn in June. After a short search for a replacement, Mary Robinette Kowal, a pro, joined the concom and took over in early July, serving through the convention.
The DC in 2021 bid was selected at Dublin 2019 in an uncontested race and conducted the 2023 Worldcon Site Selection, won by Chengdu Worldcon.
In November 2020, the concom announced it would implement a special Hugo Award category for “Best Video Game” in the 2021 Hugo Awards.
Disasters[edit]
The con was so fraught with troubles it may go down in fanhistory as Discon Disastrous.
Covid-19[edit]
It was to have been held August 25–29, 2021, at the Marriott Wardman Park and Omni Shoreham. Because of the Covid-19 epidemic, it could not be held as scheduled but was postponed to December 2021.
The con conducted a poll in December 2020 to determine fan preference, but did not release the results until April 7, 2021, due to legal issues over its hotel contracts. Two-thirds of the respondents said they preferred a live Worldcon in December over an earlier online-only event. The Worldcon still offered virtual memberships and events in addition to the in-person convention.
On August 21, 2021, DC3 announced that everyone attending would be required to present proof of vaccination. Children too young to be vaccinated and others who could not be vaccinated were not permitted to attend. Masks were mandatory.
Flare-ups of the Omicron strain of Covid-19 just before the convention caused many members to decide not to attend in person. Among them was Special Guest Malka Older, who decided to attend only virtually since her children were not old enough to be vaccinated. Since she and Sheree Renée Thomas were meant to co-host the Hugo Ceremony, the concom invited an additional special guest, Andrea Hairston, for that role.
Despite the con’s policies and members’ precautions, at least 31 attendees tested positive for Covid-19 during or just after Discon III (which had somewhere between 2000 and 3000 attendees). A January 12 report stated:
The only cluster event we saw evidence of was the WSFS Business Meeting.... The WSFS business meeting ... has a disproportionate number of cases relative to the percent of DisCon III members who attended it. Our best guess is that the WSFS business meeting involved a lot of talking, which generates more aerosols, and consistent repeated exposure. The other panel rooms were cleared every hour for a half-hour break but the business meeting was not.
Hotels[edit]
In the summer of 2020, the Marriott Wardman Park announced that the hotel, which had been closed since March due to Covid-19, might shut down permanently, with a final decision scheduled for sometime in the Fall of 2020. Subsequently, the Wardman Park’s owners filed for bankruptcy, announced the hotel’s permanent closing, and their intent to sell the property.
Controversies[edit]
Fired GoH[edit]
The convention had announced Baen Books’ Toni Weisskopf as Editor GoH. After Jason Sanford publicized on February 15, 2021, what he viewed as toxic content by some users of a few of Baen’s online forums, the concom announced it was “monitoring” the situation. Weisskopf took down the forums the next day, promising to investigate. However, Discon issued a statement on February 19, saying, in part:
DisCon III condemns the violent and hostile content found within Baen Books’ forums. We also cannot condone the fact such content was enabled and allowed to ferment for so long. We want to make it clear abusive behavior is not, and will not be, tolerated at DisCon III. Such behavior goes entirely against our already established policies concerning inclusivity and creating a welcoming environment for our members.... As a result, after discussion with her, we have notified Toni Weisskopf we are removing her as a Guest of Honor for DisCon III.
This marked the first time a Worldcon had ever removed a GoH. The decision was controversial, to say the least. Several concom members and volunteers resigned in the wake of the announcement and some con members said on social media that they would not attend.
Other controversies included Hugo Awards policies that led to mass resignations and the concom’s decision to discard the tradition of publishing names of preregistered members.
Resignations[edit]
Bill Lawhorn and Colette Fozard were originally co-chairs, but Fozard resigned in January 2021 due to abuse from the online community over the Worldcon’s (quickly rescinded) announcements regarding limits on certain credits for large teams receiving Hugo nominations. She issued a statement on File 770.
Other resignations included Jared Dashoff, the WSFS Division Head (explained here), the Hugo Administrator, the Facilities Division Heads, and several others. Then, in June 2021, the replacement Hugo Administration team resigned en masse.
Shortly afterward, a beleaguered Lawhorn resigned, according to an announcement on June 25, 2021.
Latinx Fanhistory Error[edit]
On September 3, 2021, DisCon III announced that Marguerite Smith and Lauren Raye Snow were joining the concom as vice chairs, describing Snow as “the first Latinx to serve as a Vice Chair” of a Worldcon. This was untrue, as Fred Duarte was a vice chair for LoneStarCon 2 in 1997, and for all anyone knows, someone else with that heritage may have had the job earlier yet.
Not every Worldcon has vice chairs, nobody maintains a historical listing of fans who held the title, nor have conventions generally highlighted the ethnicity of their concom members, so the initial mistake might be forgivable poor research. However, Karen Meschke, chair of LoneStarCon 2 and the late Duarte’s ex-wife, immediately contacted Discon to correct the error, asking, “Could the wording be changed to first female Latinx Vice Chair and Fred be added as a footnote?” After Meschke notified two different Discon advisors and got no action, she went public on October 19 in a guest post at File 770.
After others intervened, the online announcement was amended, with Fred mentioned in a footnote, and the correction was sent out on October 28 with no word on why it took two months.
Hugos[edit]
The first Hugo controversy had to do with policies over how many of the people behind a nominee would be listed on the ballot, engraved on the award and welcome at limited-attendance events. A second, possibly related, internal flap (see File 770) led to another round of committee resignations.
Then, among the 2021 Hugos nominations for Best Related Work was “George R.R. Martin Can Fuck Off Into the Sun, Or: The 2020 Hugo Awards Ceremony (Rageblog Edition),” a blog post critical of Martin’s performance as MC of the Hugo ceremony at CoNZealand. Since it achieved enough nominations to appear on the ballot (37), Hugo Administrator Linda Deneroff (part of the third Hugo Administration team) allowed it, apparently without considering whether it was in violation of Discon’s “established policies concerning inclusivity and creating a welcoming environment for our members.” The Code of Conduct explicitly forbade “Comments directly intended to belittle, offend, or cause discomfort including telling others they are not welcome and should leave.”
Martin was offended enough that he skipped both sponsoring the semi-official Hugos after-party he’s personally funded for many years and attending the Worldcon (the first he had missed in decades).
Editor GoH Toni Weisskopf, who was disinvited under those same policies, received sufficient nominations for the Best Editor, Long Form Hugo to appear on the ballot, but, according to the administrators, withdrew.
The awards ceremony itself was delayed for an hour due to a minor fire in the ballroom.
Christian Opening Ceremonies[edit]
Opening Ceremonies featured a concert by the Duke Ellington School of the Arts Show Choir of Washington, DC, which had been invited by Chair Mary Robinette Kowal, who had previously announced, “I was a theater kid, and as soon as I learned about the Duke Ellington School of the Arts, I knew we needed to have them involved as a true expression of D.C. We are thrilled that the students will join us both on stage and behind the scenes. The show choir’s performance will be the highlight of the Opening Ceremonies.”
What was not announced ahead of time was the choir’s program, which was devoted to Christian, gospel and Christmas music. Many Jews and other non-Christian fans found this inappropriate as part of Worldcon’s official opening event, if not offensive and a violation of Discon’s “established policies concerning inclusivity and creating a welcoming environment for our members.” No one connected to the convention ever made any official acknowledgment of the complaints.
Site Selection[edit]
See 2023 Site Selection, which was also fraught.
Raytheon Sponsorship[edit]
Discon III accepted sponsorship funds from Raytheon Intelligence and Space, a high tech, aerospace and weapons manufacturer, which some fans and pros found upsetting. After this was publicized, Chair Mary Kowal apologized post-con, saying the sponsorship did not meet Discon’s Code of Conduct and “aims to build an inclusive community for all fans.” (Online here.)
The apology offended another group of fans, many of whom work for in the aerospace and military/industrial complex. Not to mention the people who were already unhappy about other issues for which there was no apology.
Kowal further said Discon would “make an anonymous contribution to an organization dedicated to peace, equal to the amount we received from Raytheon.” However, this would appear to violate the WSFS Constitution, which requires that Worldcons “dispose of surplus funds remaining after accounts are settled for its convention for the benefit of WSFS as a whole” and “file annual financial reports regarding the disbursement of that surplus.”
Accessibility Issues[edit]
As the Omni Shoreham opened in 1930, the site had accessibility issues. There were steps between different parts of the lobby and to the main restaurant. The accessibility of parts of the hotel, coupled with the slow and small elevators, caused problems for some fans. Some programming was not accessible. There were some special elevators for people who needed them that were not marked until a day after the convention started. Due to staffing issues at the Omni Shoreham, there was no room service.
Author and access advocate Mari Ness posted about the difficulties at length, particularly condemning the con’s communications about potential issues.
Videos[edit]
Recordings of programming were made available online only for three weeks in January 2022 and accessible only to Discon III members.
Discon III Itself[edit]
Despite the many issues around Discon III, many members had an enjoyable conference, especially the opportunity to see friends in person after 21 months of Concellation. The weather was mostly warm and dry. Most of the party suites were large and the parties were well-attended.
The Exhibit Hall and Dealers Room were in a portion of the garage, which led to parking issues throughout the convention.
At-con Registration had long lines, with up to 2-hour long waits on Wednesday.
The Program was mostly held in person, with some virtual items held during the course of the convention.
Attendance:[edit]
2,359 attending members plus 952 virtual with 8,721 total members (including some 3,000 supporting memberships from China). These membership figures are from The Long List; however, Locus reported 2,359 attendees + 1,197 virtual, totaling 9,293.
Business Meeting[edit]
Besides the activity detailed under 2023 Site Selection, the notable actions of the WSFS Business Meeting were to ratify the Lodestar Award and the Best Series Hugo, passed on from 2020, and in new business, a change in memberships, which clarifies that one is paying for membership in WSFS and making that nontransferable. The motion passed and went to Chicon 8 for ratification.
As noted under Covid-19, the BM proved a cluster event.
See Also[edit]
- For other especially-troubled Worldcons, see NyCon (1939), NorWesCon (1950), Iguanacon (1978), ConStellation (1983) and Nolacon 2 (1988). The Sad and Rabid Puppies caused controversies for the 2014–16 cons, and ConJose 2 (2018) was afflicted by legal matters.
- Discon III Website.
- Discon III publications and photos on fanac.org.
- Business Meeting Agenda.
- Business Meeting videos.
- Discon III Code of Conduct.
- Hugo In Memoriam Scroll 2021.
| CoNZealand | Worldcon - Bidding - Hugos | Chicon 8 |
| BucConeer | Baltiwash Worldcons | last |
| Discon II | Discon | last |
| 2021 |
| This is a convention page. Please extend it by adding information about the convention, including dates, GoHs, convention chairman, locale, sponsoring organization, external links to convention pages, awards given, the program, notable events, anecdotes, pictures, scans of publications, pictures of T-shirts, con reports, etc. |
